Where To Find The Best Pizza Restaurants on Marco Island

If you’re visiting Marco Island and you’re looking for a quick bite to eat, you can never go wrong with pizza.

Marco Island is a popular destination for those that want to enjoy great weather, beautiful beaches, and pristine waters. If you are considering a visit to Marco Island, obtain rentals on Marco Island by contacting Remax Affinity Plus. We offer an assortment of quality rentals near the most popular attractions so that you can enjoy your trip on Marco Island to the fullest. The following are some of the best pizza spots on Marco Island. 

Sami’s Pizza & Grill

227 N Collier Blvd 

Marco Island, FL 34145

(239) 389-7499

Sami’s Pizza and Grill on Collier Boulevard serves up great pizza that is available for delivery from Marco Island to Fiddler’s Creek. Come in and enjoy the retro decor and amazing food. If you are seeking pizza, Sami’s has got you covered, along with a host of other Mediterranean, American and Middle-Eastern food. The environment here is warm, friendly and welcoming for everyone. At night, Sami’s offers a fine dining experience that you’ll also enjoy. 

Italian Deli and Market

247 N. Collier Blvd.

Marco Island, FL

(239) 394-9493

Welcome to the family-owned and operated Italian Deli and Market. This eatery has been serving the best Italian takeout since 1997. With a mission “to serve Marco Island, its residents, and its visitors the very finest in Italian fare and cuisine,” the Italian Deli and Market is sure to give you the best Italian takeout available. Choose from New York-style pizza available in regular or Sicilian crust. They also offer a variety of White pizzas such as pizza artichoke, pizza bruschetta, and quattro formaggi. In addition to pizza, Italian Deli and Market offers Italian sandwiches, dinners, soups, and salads to satiate your appetite. 

Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House

257 North Collier Blvd,

Marco Island, FL 34145

(239) 389-2433

If you are looking for some good Marco Island pizza, check out Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House. Joey’s has been family owned and operated since 1997. With only the finest and freshest ingredients, the pizza here is definitely made with love. In addition to pizza, they serve up a number of tasty Italian dishes, all of which come from home-made recipes. Joey’s offers 12” and 16” pizzas as well as an assortment of specialty pizzas. They also have calzones and stromboli. If you are looking for something extra to enjoy with your pizza, check out their wide assortment of dinner entrees, salads, sandwiches, cold and hot subs and more. They even have a kid’s and dessert menu. Joey’s offers delivery and online ordering, as well as catering and carry-out. You can dine inside or outdoors and enjoy a drink from the full bar while watching the NFL cable package. 

Davide Italian Cafe

Island Plaza (NW Corner Bald Eagle & Collier)

688 Bald Eagle Dr.

Marco Island, FL 34145

(239) 393-2233

Welcome to Davide Italian Cafe where “You’re Family”! This is the perfect spot to visit if you are seeking great pizza and other Italian options. Offering 13” and 18” pizzas in an assortment of flavors as well as stromboli and calzones, you’ll enjoy dining on pizza made from fresh ingredients. This simple cafe also offers a wide assortment of appetizers, paninis, pasta, meat dishes, desserts and wines to enjoy. With its simple, inviting ambiance, delicious food and affordable prices, dining at Davide Italian Cafe is recommended for pizza and more.

400 Pazzi’s

400 S Collier Blvd

Marco Island, FL 34145-5304

(239) 394-2511

Located in JW Marriott Marco Island, 400 Pazzi’s is a delightful, family-style restaurant that offers delicious Italian cuisine served up alongside a beautiful view of the Gulf of Mexico. The brick-oven pizza here is hearty and satisfying perfect for satisfying hunger after swimming at the beach or pool. You choose from inside or outside dining facing the pool or the beach. 400 Pazzi also accommodates special diets offering vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options.